Yet, nephi in the book of mormon is said to use a compass as early as 589 b. Obviously, if it was a magnetic compass, that is if it showed standard directions of north, south, east and west, it would not fit the mesoamerican narrative that john l. In the book of mormon, the liahona was found one morning at lehis tent door. The book of mormon provides an unparalleled perspective on covenants as the lords compass through the welter of pitfalls that characterize this mortal wilderness. While it is possible that the magnetic compass was known in the east earlier, this cannot be assumed for the purpose of providing a denotation for the book of mormon name. Thus, there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest a jewish or middleeastern migration to america. Was the liahona simply a magnetic compass that was out of place in 600 b. Book of mormon video presentation 3, i will prepare the way. The spindles worked on a different principle altogether.
Humility and willing obedience to gods commandments determine. First, i would add a word of caution that lack of evidence is not negative evidence. It helps us understand his teachings, including those in the bible. In the time of the olmecs in central america, they had a magnetic compass, between 1400 to b.
According to the book of mormon the liahona was a ball shaped object that directed the family of lehi in the direction they were supposed to travel. Galileo in the book of mormon part 3 general discussions. However, after the establishment of the farms organization in 1979, which tied itself to the directionally skewed book of mormon geography theory of john sorenson, some writers but not all even began extending that opposition to lds writers that dared broach the subject of a magnetic compass. But the liahona was more than just a simple compass in function, for it additionally required faith for correct. The book of mormon is a powerful witness of jesus christ. The earliest form of the compass magnet floating in water was invented in china sometime around 1044 ad.
I know that, as the prophet joseph smith said, the book of mormon will draw a person nearer to god than by any other book. Jul 26, 2010 later in the book of mormon, we read that the ball was prepared by the lord and was called the liahona, which is translated as a compass alma 37. The list of archaeological and historical claims of the book. Can the book of mormon narrative and other scriptures support the idea that the liahona contained a magnetic needle. Chapter sixteen of mark twains roughing it begins, all men have heard of the mormon bible, but few except the elect have seen it, or, at least, taken the trouble to read it. Magnetic compass singing time western world book of mormon inspirational books family activities insight how to find out healing liahona. Since the magnetic compass in lehis time was still many centuries from discovery, the use of the word compass by joseph smith in translation to refer to the liahona reinforces not only the analogy of directional function with the modern compass but also of design cf. Liahona compass mormonism, the mormon church, beliefs. In lehis language, liahona meant a compass see alma 37.
While perusing a small anti mormon book printed in 1832, i came across a passage in which the author sarcastically wrote, the mariners compass was only known in europe about 300 years ago. Reviewing a recent meridian article titled misunderstanding the book of mormon, by john tvedtnes, invites further observations of some subjects. With compass you wont go around in circles which is normal without a compass. The liahona working like a traditional magnetic compass. The book of mormon makes this explicit, but because the translation also uses compass and because some interpret this only to be a magnetic. Lds conference april 1971 a rebuke from president harold. Compass, coins, and other miscellaneous book of mormon. While perusing a small antimormon book printed in 1832, i came across a passage in which the author sarcastically wrote, the mariners compass was only known in europe about 300 years ago. Mesoamerican scholars have researched evidences that the olmec jaredites had knowledge of the magnetic compass, so it seems. The book of mormon claims that jewish ancestry formed the majority of precolumbian inhabitants of america. Archaeological evidence of the book of mormon latterday. The liahona is described as a compass, because it leads the way, not because it points north. The term a compass is used to describe an object called the liahona in the book of mormon. Critics were quick to ridicule the liahona, claiming that the magnetic compass was unknown in 600 b.
According to the book of mormon, the word liahona meant specifically compass alma 37. The following article is courtesy of fair, a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing welldocumented answers to criticisms of lds doctrine, belief and practice. Dec 29, 2015 a reader pointed out that magnetic compasses werent really widely used until the middle ages, and so it is more likely that the word compass in the book of mormon would have referred to the kind of compass used for measuring distances and drawing circles, perhaps related to the fact that the liahona was a ball or circular. It is described as a round brass ball of curious workmanship with two spindles, one of which indicated the direction that his party should travel 1 nephi 16. Bunker, the design of the liahona and the purpose of the second spindle question.
The book of mormons witness of jesus christ disagrees with the biblical witness of christ. That is, that it was not a magnetic compass with cardinal, inordinal and. Does the iroquois legend of the great peacemaker validate. The compass was symbolic of the words of christ just as lehis family were led to the promised land, we can be guided throughout or lives by being. This the continuation of a series of articles exploring whether the liahona that was used in the book of mormon contained a magnetic needle similar to those found in compasses today.
Lehi followed the direction indicated by the spindles, and he didnt end up at the north pole. The compass led them to the more fertile parts of the desert. There are further indications of scientific thought by galileo and his contemporaries in the design and operation of the liahona. But the compass was discovered in the late middle ages in china and was unknown in the ancient near east from which lehi sailed. The list of archeological and historical claims of the book of mormon compared to nonapologetic evidence. Anachronisms and contradictions not only does the book of mormon plagiarize heavily from the king james bible, but it betrays a great lack of information and background on the subject of world history and the history of the jewish people. A book of mormon retelling the church of jesus christ of latterday saints ester and micahs book of mormon adventures 1. Compass should not be confused with the magnetic compass which first came into use in the west generally in the middle ages. Lds conference april 1971 a rebuke from president harold b. The magnetic compass has been in existence for nearly a thousand years and is the most common type of compass. Previously ive shown galilean thought in the design of the jaredite barges, the heliocentric description of the universe, and almas faith experiment. The book of mormon makes this explicit, but because the translation also uses compass and. C to use the word compass as a name for a round or curved object is well. In order to more fully illustrate this point and apply it to the history portrayed in the book of mormon, i have decided to focus on a particular nephite cultural item a venerated instrument called the liahona alma 37.
There are several problems with this assumption, however. Purchase ship magnetism and the magnetic compass 1st edition. The book of mormon teaches that sacred covenants point the way back to our. The liahona was an object which god gave to lehi, a prophet in the book of mormon, and his family as a guide. Im not a mormon but then again maybe i am after all. The problem of the mormon tank revisited beggars bread. One of its spindles points the direction they should go in the wilderness, but only when they are righteous and trust in the lord. The following article is courtesy of fair, a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing welldocumented answers to. The design of the liahona and the purpose of the second spindle robert l. Apr 18, 2008 the liahona is described as a compass, because it leads the way, not because it points north. As lehis family is journeying toward the promised land, one morning outside lehis tent, they discover an exquisitely crafted sphereshaped compass. For the magnetic compass, i refer the reader to alan miners recent threepart series on the liahona in the meridian archive. Compass, coins, and other miscellaneous some of the supposed book of mormon anachronisms are difficult to categorize, so they are included here. Sorenson championed in his socalled 1985 landmark book an ancient american setting for the book of mormon, which most mesoamericanists use as their bible on the.
The magnetic compass of god to miracles by small means alan miner on. Does the iroquois legend of the great peacemaker validate the book of mormon of christ visiting america. A traveler who may be lost and is desperately seeking the direction that he should go in order to reach his desired destination finds a simple instrument such as a compass to be indispensable. The liahona a curious ball book of mormon evidence. Events of the earliest, by jareds group, are recounted at considerable length but with little nautical information in ether 2. One of the spindles was said to point the direction lehi and his party should travel after their escape from jerusalem, but it only worked when they were. The book of mormon mentions the word compass jump to subtopic. The book of mormon department of christian defense. Maxwell institute that the liahona was not a magnetic compass, but rather it is clearly described as a revelatory device dependent not upon magnetism but upon obedience to the lord 1 nephi 18. But the compass was discovered in the late middle ages in china and was unknown in the ancient near east from which lehi sailed in modern english, the word compass usually denotes a device with a magnetized needle. A compass is an instrument containing a magnetized pointer that shows the direction of magnetic north and bearings from it. A dry form of the compass was invented in europe around 0 ad until it was replaced in the 1800s by a liquidfilled magnetic version. Ive used this compass for 30 years in my profession with excellent results. The word compass as used here does not refer to the magnetic instrument of the mariner the magnetic compass was apparently not known in the western world until about the twelfth century a.
Its directing capability came not from a magnetic field but rather according to. Dec 10, 2007 the golden compass, the holy bible, the book of mormon, etc. Mar 26, 2018 obviously, if it was a magnetic compass, that is if it showed standard directions of north, south, east and west, it would not fit the mesoamerican narrative that john l. The golden compass, the holy bible, the book of mormon, etc. Its not only not externally integrated with true north it hasnt. According to the book of mormon and other latter day saint movement sources, the liahona. Such a spindleshaped pointer is often encountered in magnetic compasses cf. The golden compass, the holy bible, the book of mormon. The book of mormon refers to the liahona as a compass not because it anachronistically pointed the way to travel, but because it was a perfectly round object. The design of the liahona and the purpose of the second spindle. Compass, coins, and other miscellaneous book of mormon anachronisms part 6 by michael r. The magnetic compass of god to miracles by small means magnetic compass. Sep 05, 2010 does the iroquois legend of the great peacemaker validate the book of mormon of christ visiting america. It is sometimes referred to as a compass, although the context makes it clear that it did not function like a magnetic compass.
George reynolds has explained the differences between. In order to adjust a magnetic compass to due or true north and toward the geographic north pole, one must know the amount of magnetic declination or variation that exists in a specific region. To read the introduction to this series, click here. John dehlin december 10, 2007 mormon 5 comments this is a somewhat fun comparison between the golden compass and the holy bible, which, at a minimum, tries to put into perspective the antigolden compass rhetoric out there which is even going around mormon lds wards and email lists. While the book of mormon does not tell us whether the liahona functioned partly on geomagnetic principles, nephi did say that it contained two spindles, one of which functioned as a directional pointer, and that the body was made of fine brass 1 nephi 16. Oct 11, 2019 the book of mormon refers to the liahona as a compass not because it anachronistically pointed the way to travel, but because it was a perfectly round object. Take a fascinating journey back into the ancient navigational history of the liahona and learn about technologies, like the magnetic compass, that was. Ship magnetism and the magnetic compass 1st edition. Secondly, there is no reason to think that the liahona operated like a magnetic compass. Jan 31, 2020 the compass is an instrument used for navigation. Coins the term coins is never actually used in the book of mormon text.
Jun 07, 20 a compass is an instrument containing a magnetized pointer that shows the direction of magnetic north and bearings from it. See more ideas about book of mormon, lds seminary and lds. There are online maps and calculators available that provide the difference in declination between true north and magnetic north for every point on the globe. The liahona, a compass, and the hebrew language book of mormon.
Later in the book of mormon, we read that the ball was prepared by the lord and was called the liahona, which is translated as a compass alma 37. The mormon tank mormonism is like a tank the compass may appear to be true while youre inside after all it feels right and everything seems to nicely integrated, correlated, unified, logical, rational and working but all the while the mormon tank is corrupting the end result. The liahona is described as a round ball, made of brass, with two pointers that gave directions, similar to a compass. The three crossings of the ocean to the new world reported in the book of mormon are treated in differing degrees of detail. The magnetic compass of god to miracles by small means.
413 963 1182 1460 746 41 1015 122 1302 160 1186 1332 1430 1152 234 721 311 1054 1108 1560 1460 1089 987 978 144 252 1472 114 868 1384 635 1521 1029 800 1444 30 436 1426 810 318 1034 656 263